Local favorites
Local favorites
Where to Thrift in Rockland County: 13 Shops Worth the Trip
The short answer
The best places to thrift in Rockland County include Goodwill in Nanuet for the biggest selection, Trilogy Consignment in Nyack and Thrift by Elite Repeat in New City for designer pieces, charity shops like Grace's in Nyack, Tappan Zee Thrift Shop in Piermont and the Hudson Valley Humane Society Thrift Shop in Pomona, and Bricktown Furniture in Haverstraw for secondhand furniture. Many small shops keep limited hours, so call ahead.
You don't have to leave Rockland County to thrift well. From designer consignment in Nyack and New City to church-basement bargains in Suffern, the county has a real thrift scene. You just have to know where to look. Here's the full guide, organized by what each shop does best.
Designer consignment
Thrift by Elite Repeat, New City
170 S Main St, Store #6, New City · (845) 499-2569
Sun 12–4 · Tue 11–6 · Wed–Thu 11–7 · Fri 11–6 · Sat 11–5
The place for designer handbags, shoes, jewelry, and women's clothing. Consignment-boutique quality without the boutique prices.
Trilogy Consignment, Nyack
5 S Broadway, Nyack · (845) 480-5980 · Instagram: @consigntrilogy.nyack
Sun 12–5 · Wed–Fri 12–6 · Sat 11–6
A curated consignment boutique for handbags, shoes, and jewelry, with alterations in-house. They take both vintage and modern pieces, as long as they're stylish and in good shape. Consignors book appointments, so check the site before bringing a bag of clothes.
Maria's Consignment, Nyack
240 Main St, Nyack · (201) 424-8349
Mon–Fri 10–7 · Sat 11–4
Everyday secondhand clothes on Main Street. There's no website, so call ahead if you're making a special trip.
Classic thrift
Goodwill NYNJ, Nanuet
Route 59, Nanuet · (845) 624-0187
Open daily, 10–6
The big one. The most inventory, the most turnover, and the easiest hours in the county. Start here if you're new to thrifting in Rockland.
Grace's Thrift Shop, Nyack
10 S Broadway, Nyack · (845) 358-7488
Tue–Wed 1:30–4 · Thu–Sat 11–4
An all-volunteer charity shop founded in 1968, selling donated and consigned clothing, housewares, jewelry, art, bedding, linens, and toys, but not furniture. It's cash only, and proceeds support local charities including Habitat for Humanity Rockland, Meals on Wheels, and the Nyack Senior Center.
Tappan Zee Thrift Shop, Piermont
454 Piermont Ave, Piermont · (845) 359-5753
Sun, Tue–Sat 1–5
A volunteer-run vintage treasure trove in Piermont. Pins, china, ornaments, $1 baskets, and plenty of surprises. No furniture. Donations are tax-deductible, and purchases support local charities including the Piermont and Blauvelt libraries and Hi Tor Animal Care Center.
Hudson Valley Humane Society Thrift Shop, Pomona
200 Quaker Road, Pomona · (845) 354-3124
Sat–Sun 11–3 · Call to confirm hours
Run by the Hudson Valley Humane Society on the grounds of its no-kill animal shelter. Expect women's, men's and children's clothing and shoes (some with designer labels), handbags, housewares, kitchen items, electronics, books, toys, games and artwork. Every purchase helps care for the shelter's animals.
Nearly New Thrift Shop, Spring Valley
175 NY-59, Spring Valley · (845) 641-0682
Sun 8–8 · Mon/Wed 8–5 · Tue/Thu 8–9 · Fri 8–12
Bigger than the name suggests: furniture, housewares, electronics, baby gear, and clothing, with generous hours most days.
Second Time Around, Suffern
65 Washington Ave, Suffern · (845) 357-1615
Tue & Sat 10–2 only
A church-run thrift ministry with clothing, housewares, and furniture at extremely low prices. The catch is the hours. Two mornings a week, so plan around them.
Furniture & home
Bricktown Furniture, Haverstraw
9 New Main St, Haverstraw · (845) 271-4566
Sun 10:30–5 · Mon–Sat 10–8
Used and consignment furniture, plus refinishing and upholstery if you find a piece with good bones that needs work. A natural stop if you're furnishing a new place.
Wow! That's Unusual!, Suffern
22 Lafayette Ave, Suffern · (845) 918-1352
Sun 10–5 · Tue–Thu 10–8 · Fri–Sat 12–10
Consignment, vintage, collectibles, jewelry, sports memorabilia, furniture, and décor. The inventory turns over constantly, so no two visits are the same. Open late on weekends.
Sucasa, Ramapo
144 NY-59, Unit 107, Ramapo · (845) 777-8445
Sun 11–7 · Mon–Thu 10–8 · Fri 10–2
Secondhand appliances and housewares on the Route 59 corridor. The practical stop when you need something that works, not just something pretty.
Oak Armoire, Ramapo
19 Lyncrest Dr, Ramapo
Thrift and consignment clothing with an online shop. No published store hours, so check the site or call before going.
Before you go
- Small charity shops keep short hours. Second Time Around is only open Tuesday and Saturday mornings; the Humane Society shop is open weekends; Grace's is closed Sunday and Monday; Tappan Zee doesn't open until 1pm.
- Bring cash to Grace's. It's cash only.
- Hours change. A quick call before you drive saves a wasted trip, especially at the volunteer-run shops.
Your turn
What's your best Rockland thrift find? And if you're furnishing a new home in Rockland County, thrifting it is half the fun. Happy hunting.
Frequently asked questions
Where is the biggest thrift store in Rockland County?
Goodwill NYNJ on Route 59 in Nanuet has the largest selection and the most turnover, and it is open every day from 10 to 6.
Which Rockland County town has the best thrift shopping?
Nyack has the most shops within walking distance: Trilogy Consignment, Maria's Consignment and Grace's Thrift Shop are all on or near Main Street and Broadway. Suffern is a close second, with Second Time Around and Wow! That's Unusual!.
Where can I find vintage clothing and collectibles in Rockland County?
Tappan Zee Thrift Shop in Piermont is known for vintage pins, china and ornaments. Wow! That's Unusual! in Suffern carries vintage, collectibles and sports memorabilia, and Trilogy Consignment in Nyack takes stylish vintage pieces alongside modern ones.
Where can I buy used furniture in Rockland County?
Bricktown Furniture in Haverstraw sells used and consignment furniture and offers refinishing and upholstery. Wow! That's Unusual! in Suffern and Nearly New Thrift Shop in Spring Valley also carry furniture.
Where can I find designer consignment in Rockland County?
Thrift by Elite Repeat in New City and Trilogy Consignment in Nyack both specialize in designer handbags, shoes, jewelry and clothing.
What is the best day to go thrifting?
Many regulars shop on weekday mornings, when stores are quieter and weekend donations have been put out. Ask your favorite shop when it restocks, and remember that several of Rockland's volunteer-run shops are only open a few days a week.
Which Rockland thrift shops support local charities?
Grace's Thrift Shop in Nyack and Tappan Zee Thrift Shop in Piermont are volunteer-run and donate proceeds to local charities. The Hudson Valley Humane Society Thrift Shop in Pomona supports its no-kill animal shelter. Second Time Around in Suffern is a church-run thrift ministry, and Nearly New Thrift Shop in Spring Valley is run by Kupath Ezrah of Rockland County.
Get to know Rockland County
Here are a few towns worth getting to know:


